Smecta or Polisorb: which is better, and whether it is possible at the same time

The similarity of characteristics Pharmaceuticals

Polisorb considered indirect analogue of Smecta.

If we compare the drugs, you will see the following similarities:

• Polisorb and Smecta are enterosorbents group. The active ingredients of drugs bind and remove toxins, without damaging the wall of the digestive tract and without harming the intestinal microflora. Contribute to the reduction of intoxication;
• Medicaments well tolerated and rarely give side effects;
• Means are available in powder form to prepare a slurry;
• Medicines dispensed in the pharmacy network without a prescription;
• Preparations are non-toxic and not absorbed through the mucosa of the gastrointestinal tract. At higher doses there is no overdose;
insta story viewer
• Funds allowed to give pregnant women and infants;
• Both drugs are affordable;
• Medications are used as adjunct therapy. In addition to prescribing sorbents necessary to eliminate the cause of intoxication and intestinal disorders.

Despite the fact that drugs are analogues and are well remove toxins before undertaking the replacement should be familiar with the differences.

Buy Polisorb or pick Smecta

To find out what is best to help and what is the difference between smectite and polysorbate, take a look at what is indicated in the accompanying annotations to the drugs.

polisorb

The instructions for use about Polisorb reads as follows:

• active ingredient - colloidal silicon dioxide;
• efficiency - is able to capture and almost all kinds of toxic substances, and can bind pathogens;
• infectious diseases application Polysorb reduces fever;
• shows the case of poisoning, intoxication infectious, eliminating hangover and for preventive treatment GIT;
• Propafenone displays the body of vitamins and calcium;
• course of treatment can last up to 2 weeks.

Almost all of these characteristics are inherent in all sorbents, so you should familiarize yourself with the features of other drugs.

Smecta

Let's see what is said in the summary pro Smecta:

• active ingredient - dioektatichesky smectite;
• therapeutic effect - the binding and elimination of toxins and pathogenic microorganisms;
• drug compatibility between taking Smecta and taking other medicines should be at least an hour, otherwise hard uptake of drugs;
• protection from damage - the suspension coats the mucous membranes and protects against aggressive influence of digestive juices;
• Indications for use include diarrhea of ​​any etiology, intoxication, dyspepsia, poisoning;
• particular influence on the organism: gastroprotective, enveloping and enterosorbiruyuschee action;
• Duration of 5-7 days, if you drink longer, there is constipation.

Smecta is one of the most popular drugs for the treatment of infants, preschool children and pregnant women, but other adults are reluctant to take the drug, believing it "childish" medicine.

After reviewing the basic characteristics of medicines, can pass to the differences.

What is the difference medicines

If Polisorb compared with smectite, it is possible to identify the following differences:

• Structure. Drugs will contain different active ingredients;
• Strength of. According to medical studies, Polisorb almost 3 times more effective Smecta;
• Adverse reactions. Allergy to smectite occurs more frequently than Polisorb;
• Effects on body. Polysorb only toxins, and further protects mucous Smekta from the aggressive action of digestive juices and food particles from irritation;
• Reception with other medications. For POLYSORB allowed the combined use with other agents, and if therapy is smectite, between receiving the sorbent and other medications must be at least an hour. If you break this rule, a portion of medications, rather than enter into the blood, will be connected elements of Smecta and eliminated from the body through the intestines.

Despite minor differences, smectite can be replaced with polysorbate and vice versa. But, before replacement, should consult a physician. This is due to the fact that people who are prone to constipation, Smecta trigger constipation. And if in addition to the absorbent action is necessary to protect the digestive system, the Polyphepan will be ineffective.

Is it possible to co-administration of funds

If drugs are different in composition, it is possible to drink at the same time Smecta and Polisorb? if it helps get rid of the toxins? Consider how the drug must be such combination:

• Efficiency. Each of the drugs is quite effective for binding harmful substances. Sharing will not harm the body, but does not speed up the healing process;
• Convenience. Take medication can not be consecutive, between the use of Smecta and POLYSORB must be at least an hour. It is not always convenient for the patient.

When expressed dyspeptic manifestations induced intoxication or poisoning Smekta with polysorbitol It will help to improve the patient's condition, but in most cases, this drug combination is convenient and does not need to treatment.

What else can be taken

In addition to these sorbents to reduce toxicity we may be used:

• Activated carbon. To date, the means is not very popular due to fact that the drug has a tablet form. Even zapivaniya more water soluble tablets are not always completely and particulate dosage forms can injure the mucosa. Coal has adsorbent properties, binds the toxic substance;
• enterosgel. Available in a jelly-like mass, packaged in tubes. Its activity is lower Polyphepan, but one and a half times higher than the efficiency of Smecta. The drug not only helps with the different kinds of intoxication, additional medications can facilitate the patient's condition at the stagnation of bile and other violations of liver function;
• Polyphepan. Sorbent high detoxification activity. In action similar to smectite and polysorbate. But in addition to toxic substances, Polyphepan displays the body of excess bilirubin, urea and cholesterol. Means, used not only to eliminate the toxicity, but also to reduce the signs of atherosclerosis and reducing plasma liver enzymes;
• Laktrofiltrum. Combined means which keep apart ehnterosorbentov lactulose conducive to growth of saprophytic bacteria in the gut. Acceptance of the drug reduces the toxicity and helps get rid of the signs of dysbiosis.

Polisorb and Smecta combine well with all of the medicines listed above, but in some cases, a similar technique would be inappropriate. This is due to the fact that taking 2 identical action of the drug and the person at least does not harm their health (Sorbents are not absorbed through the GI tract), but also by the joint use drug treatment effect does not increases. Not worth the extra drink Polisorb and other sorbents - is a waste of money.

Polisorb and Smecta: interchangeable or not

Consider, when allowed to replace Polisorb on smectite and vice versa, and when necessary soedovat doctor's instructions.

Resolve the situation:

• Moderate intoxication caused by poisoning or disease. Polisorb or Smecta - selection often based on physician preferences, and change is not reflected in the quality of treatment;
• Diarrhea and other diarrheal disorders caused by indigestion. Smecta and Polisorb equally well to help in these conditions.

But the replacement is not desirable in the following cases:

• The pathological process is accompanied by damage to the gastrointestinal mucosa. Polisorb only reduce intoxication and Smecta, thanks to enveloping and gastroprotective properties provide, in addition to detoxification, additional protection;
• State is accompanied by a high concentration of toxins. In this case, better to choose Polisorb as more active.

Polisorb or Smecta that will help? This question is impossible to give a definite answer. The choice depends on the characteristics of the patient's condition and the nature of the pathological process.

sources:

Vidal: https://www.vidal.ru/drugs/smecta__21502
GRLS: https://grls.rosminzdrav.ru/Grls_View_v2.aspx? routingGuid = 8c9f8fba-b794-4036-87db-566d0904c085 & t =

Found a bug? Select it and press Ctrl + Enter